Contents

Contents

05.

Retail Market

Simina Niculita

Partner | Romania
Head of Retail Agency

THE BIG FIGURES

New supply

2023

226,000 sqm/year

in

15 new schemes

(vs 84,500 sqm​ in 2022 and 127,500/year in the last 5 years)

2024
projected

83,500 sqm ​

Biggest additions

1

Promenada Mall Craiova(NEPI RockCastle)

63,700 sqm

(biggest shopping center delivered since 2016)

2

AFI Arad (AFI Europe)

29,400 sqm

3

Carolina Mall (Prime Kapital/MAS REI)

28,900 sqm

Consumer story

Wage growth

+15.1%

YoY in Nov-23

vs

+13.4%

YoY in Dec-22

Inflation

6.6%

in Dec-23

vs

16.4%

in Dec-22

Unemployment rate

5.4%

in Nov-23

vs

5.6%

in Dec-22

Supply

Around 220,000 sqm of new modern shopping centers were added in 2023, with the bulk of this surface coming from just 3 schemes: NEPI Rockcastle’s mall Promenada Craiova – 63,700 sqm, AFI Europe’s AFI Arad retail park – 29,400 sqm and Prime Kapital/MAS REI’s Carolina Mall in Alba Iulia – 28,900 sqm. The first of these is also the biggest retail scheme delivered in Romania since 2016’s ParkLake in Bucharest. While this is a bit lower than the c.260,000 sqm of new projects developers were promising at the start of the year, it is nevertheless more than double what we have seen in the past couple of years and also one of the best results in almost a decade, so overall, a good year in terms of new supply. Otherwise, it is a much more balanced distribution than in the recent past, with new projects targeting both bigger cities (including Bucharest this time around) as well as smaller towns, with the latter being at the forefront of retailers’ expansion. It is worth pointing out that we only take into account shopping schemes above a GLA of 5,000 sqm.

Demand

2023 started under gloomier terms for the consumer, as inflation was still quoted in double digit territory at around 15% and wages were expanding below this level. Also, economic growth was a bit lower throughout the year than what was expected back in Q1 2023, though Romania still did better than most of its European peers given the context. Furthermore, job creation continued slowing down through last year, though still held quite decent levels and the labour market remained tight as a consequence. This, alongside two increases in the minimum pay, kept salaries decent and as of March 2023, real wage growth (meaning the difference between the annual dynamic of wages and that of prices) shifted back in positive territory. By end-2023, the c.9% increase in real wages was already comparable to pre-pandemic levels.

Amid this context, the retail segment had a good year and though the first half of the year was rather hit and miss, the second half of the year saw a significant uptick in spending. Early indicators of November and December show quite robust results and given how relevant these months tend to be for retailers, it is safe to assume that 2023 was another good year both retailers and landlords.

Wages are again comfortably outpacing consumer price growth

Source: National Institute of Statistics

We recall the fact that, as per Eurostat’s readings, Romania tend to offer some of the highest (in many cases, the highest) gross margins in the EU for a variety of types of goods, from clothing to footwear to toys to pharmaceutical. While the cost of risk is more significant than in other countries, and this can impact the bottom line when taking out a loan for example, we view this as a sign of a still undersupplied market in terms of retail schemes and a market which can accommodate new players. Indeed, last year saw new brands making their way to Romania, such as Lefties, Jimmy Kay, Wittchen or Stefanel (the latter is a re-entry, as the brand exit the market completely back in 2021). That said, after years of hefty price increases, the discounter segment of the market has continued to do well through 2023 and should see favourable dynamics.

Rents & Vacancy

In general, occupancy remains solid for most shopping centers, with the newly delivered schemes generally well received by the market. Meanwhile, dominant malls still have virtually non-existent available spaces. On the rental side, despite the slowdown in sales, it is important to note that sales remain comfortably above pre-pandemic levels.

Outlook

With around 80,000 sqm of new modern retail schemes due to be delivered this year (and more than half coming from a single scheme – Arges Mall in Pitesti), it is quite the downgrade versus last year and rather comparable to the softer years right after the pandemic start. There is a bit of a difference, however, as we can see around the corner, during 2025-2028, quite a few large dominant shopping centers which would add several hundreds of thousands of GLA to the local retail stock. Iulius Group’s new Cluj-Napoca mall has, based on initial promises, a GLA of over 100,000 sqm, with a fresh scheme in the same town from the Prime Kapital/MAS REI joint venture to deliver in excess of 70,000 sqm of leasable retail areas. Elsewhere, in Iasi, the latter JV will also deliver an expansion of nearly 60,000 sqm to Mall Moldova by the end of 2025; there are also quite a lot of other large projects underway (or where works should commence soon) with a GLA of somewhere between 30,000 to 50,000 sqm. While Romania’s real estate segments remain quite undersupplied relative to other European countries (including those in the region), evidence suggests that the gap is smaller for retail than for office or industrial markets on a relative (per capita) basis.

Further available stock for general retailers could come over the medium term from large FMCG operators aiming to optimize their occupied surface as more and more people order food online or simply shop at proximity supermarkets rather than go to larger hypermarkets. Some hypermarkets with over 12,000-15,000 sqm of occupied surface may want to scale it down with up to half of this, leading to a quite significant extra stock that could be leased to a wide array of retail tenants, mostly those found in retail parks.

Retail schemes deliveries (GLA) by town population size

Source: Colliers

Overall, despite the slowdown in 2024 relative to 2023, the medium-term pipeline is not at all a poor one, quite the contrary. In fact, we need to note the fact that the appetite of developers has returned for sizeable retail schemes as well, which tend to carry a bigger investment footprint; up until 2022, the previous years were mostly dominated by retail parks, with a lot of these targeting small and medium-sized cities with a subpar coverage of modern retail schemes.

As a special note, we need to acknowledge the rising presence of local capital on the development side, with local businessmen delivering consistently more schemes; furthermore, the divestment of Mitiska REIMs retail park portfolio as well as potential future such sales could cement a model of “build, lease, sell” which, in turn, could attract more capital for retail expansion in Romania.

Otherwise, the shift in mindset towards bigger projects shows an increased risk appetite and confidence in the country’s longer-term path. Furthermore, there is still room for such sizeable shopping in many big cities, including Bucharest; the issue has been, rather, securing adequate land plots with good infrastructure connectivity.

On the latter aspect, it is also quite important to note the fast-track progress that Romania is seeing in terms of improving the country’s infrastructure; such works can boost the economic attractiveness of certain areas (particularly in Moldavia or some southern regions), leading to job creation and an improved spending prospects. In other areas, infrastructure works can open up or improve the appeal of whole new regions of the town (like the southern ring road highway around Bucharest).

On the consumers’ side, we should see favourable trends over the medium term. On the one hand, inflation is expected to continue decreasing; after ending 2023 at 6.6%, it should re-enter the central bank’s target interval of 1.5-3.5% by the end of next year (fiscal policy permitting). Meanwhile, economic activity is set to accelerate, which should mean job creation, which, in turn, should pressure employers to hand out bigger wages amid the relatively tight labour market. All in all, we would expect retail sales to accelerate in 2024-2025 relative to 2023.

Projects to be delivered in 2024