Contents

Contents

07.

Investment Market

Robert Miklo

Director | Romania
CEE | Investment Services

THE BIG FIGURES

Gross take-up

€476 mn

in 2023

vs

€1,249 mn

in 2022

and

€921 mn / year

average for the previous 5 years

Major deals of 2023

1

Mitiska REIM divested their 25 retail park portfolio​ to British M Core​ (new entry) for €219 million, the biggest retail deal a decade

2

CTP purchased​ FM Logistics’ c.100,000 sqm​ warehouse portfolio in a sale-and-leaseback deal estimated around €60 million

Country risk

10Y local currency bond yield:

7.32%

in Jan-24

vs

7.26%

in Jan-23

Romanian equity risk premium (Damodaran):

7.81%

in Jan-24

vs

9.73%

in Jan-23

Yields

Prime office yields

7.25 - 7.75%

in Q4 2023

vs

6.75%

in Q4 2022

Prime industrial yields

7.25 - 7.75%

in Q4 2023

vs

7.50%

in Q4 2022

Prime retail yields

7.00 - 7.50%

in Q4 2023

vs

6.75%

in Q4 2022

Prime residential yields

4.75 - 5.25%

in Q4 2023

vs

4.50%

in Q4 2022

CEE investment market

As expected, 2023 turned out to be a somewhat soft year for the investment scene in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), with the volumes in the CEE-6 countries (Bulgaria, Czechia, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Slovakia) down by 54% over a year earlier, at €4.9 billion; this is the lowest level since 2012’s approximately €4 billion result. The sharp increase in the cost of money and less favourable outlook for certain real estate sectors sapped investor demand, though the decline is more or less comparable with other European markets. Yields moved higher almost across the board in the CEE-6 region, which is also in line with similar dynamics in the advanced economies.

Prime yields at the end of 2023 (compared to end-2022 yields)

*to account for a less active investment scene in Romania, particularly to a lack of benchmark deals involving prime assets, we quote yields for Romania within a certain interval until more clarity can be achieved

Romanian Investment Market

Overview

2023 turned out to be more or less in line with where we saw things at the start of the year, with overall volumes dipping to €476 million, down more than half over 2022’s cycle high of €1.25 billion. While the decline is more severe than in other neighbouring CEE peers, it is worth pointing out how exceptional 2022 was; in fact, if we were to compare to the average for the last 5 years (~€920 million), Romania actually did perform a bit better than other countries in the region (48% decline compared to a 58% drop for the CEE-6 region relative to the 2018-2022 average). It is also worth pointing out that other more mature markets saw declines more or less in the same ballpark as the high interest rates, economic slowdown and heightened uncertainties about the global economy took their toll.

Romanian investment market (€) volumes by sector

Source: Colliers

As in the past, what tends to make or break a year is the presence or lack of major deals. And while some were on the agenda at the start of the year (and some fell through later), one major transaction that closed last year helped freshen the overall result. It was the sale of Mitiska REIMs 25 retail assets portfolio to a new entry, British fund M Core, for €219 million. The latter is particularly important as it is the most significant new name we have seen on the local market in a while, particularly as we have seen many Western European funds circling Romania, but not pulling the trigger on any deals.

Overall, many market participants remained in a wait-and-see mood, partly reflecting also the more difficult financing context (more on that below).

Transactions

As previously stated, the year’s biggest deal by far (and also the biggest retail transaction in Romania for many years) was the sale of Mitiska REIM’s retail park portfolio, made up of some two dozen properties. The year’s second biggest transaction was the sale-and-leaseback of FM Logistics industrial portfolio, a deal we estimate roughly around €60 million, purchased by CTP, the leader of the local I&L market. The third biggest deal saw the sale of One United’s One Herastrau Office to a new name for the local market, Latvian group Vincit Union, for around €21 million.

Other standout deals saw state entities purchasing real estate assets for various purposes (like the Sibiu City Hall buying a building for the local theater or the medical university in Bucharest purchasing a building, likely for educational purposes); while these are by no means comparable in size to private investments and make up a small share, it is noteworthy that up until a few years ago, public institutions’ presence on the local market was even lower. Another such sector largely absent from the investment market was that of local asset managers, though 2023 did see one of the big players locally, BT Asset Management, pull the trigger on a few medical clinics in a sale-and-leaseback transaction.

Prices and funding conditions

The greatly reduced funding availability coupled with the higher interest rates have been largely driving prices lower/yields higher over the last year and a half throughout much of the world, including in Romania. It is worth mentioning, however, that Romania largely missed the downward move in yields over the last decade or so (particularly in the initial phase of the post-pandemic recovery story), and now it is also seeing a shallower correction than other countries. That said, we still see that yields have moved outward a bit last year; given that we lack major benchmark deals that would actually show where the market is, we prefer to quote yields via an interval presently. Consequently, we see prime office yields in Romania at 7.25-7.75% at the end of last year (versus 6.75% at the end of 2022), prime retail yields at 7-7.50% (versus 6.75% at the end of 2022) and prime industrial yields at 7.25-7.75% (versus 7.50% at the end of the previous year).

When looking at the funding conditions, there are quite a few changes compared to a few years ago. Firstly, availability is far from a sure thing as certain aspects weigh more than they did in the past, like the sponsor or how future-proof a real estate project is given its ESG credentials. Furthermore, the banks’ appetite is quite limited for certain real sectors, offices in particular, though, again, a lot depends on the sponsor and exceptions can be made. Industrial assets rank much higher on the banks’ list, followed by retail and residential, where decisions are rather on a case by case basis. Loan margins are some 300-350 basis for a prime asset when a loan is offered, but it is worth pointing out that two years ago, the market was 100 basis points lower.

Outlook

It is quite difficult to say where the market will land over the short term and in spite of our quite bullish view for the Romanian economy (which translates to optimism regarding the country’s real estate markets), we cannot help but have a cautious approach regarding the this year. Interest rates in advanced economies are set to start moving lower sometime by the middle of the year, including EUR interest rates which are of great importance to the local market. However, central banks shall not be moving the cost of money lower at the same speed with which they hiked rates over the last year and a half, so any expectations of a material relief are unfounded, in our opinion. Rather, there is room for the second half of the year to look slightly better and for funding conditions to ease a bit.

Prime office capital values suggest offices have reduced the gap to Germany/Poland recently, suggesting pressures on yields remain skewed to the upside

Source: Colliers

Meanwhile, the major deals’ pipeline at the start of 2024 (i.e. deals which could close by year-end) is comparable to 2023’s full year commercial real estate investment volume, at over €500 million. As with past years, a single deal (Globalworth’s industrial portfolio) accounts for a significant share of the potential pipeline (around half), so how good 2024 will look in a year from now hinges greatly on this single deal. This is also an important deal in terms of benchmarking of interest for the local industrial scene, where the major developers tend to be long-time holders. It would also be the single biggest industrial platform to exchange hands locally.

The pipeline also includes several other sizeable retail and office assets, including some potential deals which could serve as valuable benchmarks for where the market is with regards to yields. Given the widening gap in terms of where buyers are and what sellers want, it has been difficult to accurately price local assets. We expect 2024 to at least offer better clarity on this front, particularly if some of the previously mentioned deals close.

It is also worth mentioning that we could see funding rollover requirements generating some deals and leading to a bit more activity on the investment market, as some owners may find it too difficult to refinance at these high interest rates alongside a hefty depreciation of the standing asset.

Amid this backdrop, we feel that pressures on some yields (in particular office assets and, to a somewhat lesser extent, retail properties) remain skewed to the upside and we may very well see the market move a bit higher. Industrials are more of a tricker proposition to value; while the higher cost of risk and lack of general clarity about the global economy act as negative factors, the I&L sector in Romania has a particularly rosy longer-term outlook. Furthermore, the sector has seen asking rents jump some 30% over the past two years. Consequently, this together with the robust growth outlook for the local market amid re-shoring, could help industrial yields move a bit sharper over the next couple of years and maybe be the first major sector to see favourable price action.

A factor worth mentioning that could impact trading volumes over the longer term is what we would call the “primary market” of prime office buildings, i.e. buildings delivered by companies which have a business model summed up by the following: building, lease, sell. With only a handful of buildings that could be delivered over the next couple of years, this could impact things down the line when/if the appetite for offices returns.